B l o g g i n g   F o r   M i c h i g a n
Mobile Edition



Subscribe to our newsletter

Preview




S O L I D A R I T Y




BFM Video


President Obama Weekly Address: 8/28/2010


Press Conference on the Michigan Supreme Court


Meet Virg Bernero


Pure Michigan- "Fresh"

BFM YouTube Channel





Michigan Bad Guys

BFM was Censored by Mike Bishop Aug 2-7, 2007


· The diabolical Obstructo Man!
· The Mike Bishop Diaries
· The Censorship Diaries


Michigan Political Parties
The Democratic Party

· Michigan Democratic Party
· MI Blue Tiger Democrats
· County Parties
· Caucuses
· Congressional District Committees
· Benzie Dems
· Blue Chips (CMU Dems)
· Clare County Democratic Party
· Genessee County Young Dems
· Grosse Pointe Dems
· Isabella County Dems
· Kicking Ass (UM Dems)
· Living Blue (Liv Co Dems)
· Saginaw County Dems
· WMU College Dems

The Green Party

· Michigan Green Party
· Detroit Green Party
· Flint Greens
· Huron Valley Greens
· Ypsilanti Greens
· All MI Green Party Organizations

Other Minor Parties

· Libertarian Party of MI
· Socialist Party of MI
· Independence Party of MI



BFM Hits   Granholm    Schauer    Bishop    Dillon    Economy    Senate Dems    Search BFM


The Answer to Michigan's Canadian Trash Problem?

by: AikoAdam

Sat Jan 26, 2008 at 15:06:48 PM EST


( - promoted by wizardkitten)

Every year, Michigan imports 19-20% of it's total landfill usage, equaling over ten million tons a year. So we bury the trash in a hole and when the hole is full we cover it up. But there's a new technology that can change the way we look at trash, what we do with it and how we can benefit from it.

It's called plasma arc gasification. In an actually not so complicated system the converter turns trash into syngas and inert byproduct. In this system garbage is run into an air tight chamber with plasma torches reaching up to 13,871°C causing pyrolysis. Pyrolysis is when organic material breaks down to it's elements without the use of combustion. The byproducts of this system are syngas, slag, and heat.

AikoAdam :: The Answer to Michigan's Canadian Trash Problem?
Looking at the byproducts

Syngas is mostly made up of hydrogen and carbon monoxide. This gas is then converted to electricity used to power the plant  itself, usually using 1/3-2/3 of the output depending on the size of the plant, and the remaining electricity is sold to third party utility companies. The amount of gas produced by a plant depends on how much organic material is used.

Slag is the solid byproduct from the process. Now before you wrinkle up your nose at it, let's look at what it is. According to Dr. Louis Circeo of Georgia Tech's Plasma Department:

   * The weight of the slag is about 20 percent of the weight of the original waste
   * The volume of the slag is about 5 percent that of the original waste''s volume

So it's smaller. That's good. But there's more uses for it as well. When the slag is air cooled it turns into obsidian like rocks that can be used in the construction industry for things such as pavement. Also the molten slag can be molded into paving stones, bricks or any manner of things. If compressed air is introduced into the molten slag stream it creates rock wool.

It''s light and wispy, and according to Dr. Circeo, it has the potential to revolutionize the plasma waste treatment industry. Rock wool is a very efficient insulation material, twice as effective as fiberglass. It's also lighter than water, but very absorbent. Because of this, it could potentially be used to help contain and clean oil spills in the ocean. Cleanup crews could spread rock wool over and around an oil spill. The rock wool would float on the water while soaking up the oil, making collection a relatively easy process. Hydroponic growing systems can also use rock wool -- farmers can plant seeds in slabs or blocks of it.

The slag is "unleachable"- any hazardous materials are inert and cannot dissolve from the slag.

And then there's heat. I hope everyone understands heat so I'm not going to explain it.

Coming soon to a landfill near you?

As I was researching this new technology and thinking about it's use in Michigan in dealing with the imported trash issue, I found out I'm not the only one thinking about it. Macomb County is currently looking at entering into agreement with Suncrest Energy LLC, a Washington Township based company for a plasma conversion plant. Democratic County Commissioner Paul Gieleghem says

"It's an incredible benefit for future generations," "Right now municipal solid waste is sitting in a hole and endangering our groundwater."

The plant could be up and running within 2 years. Plasma conversion plants are currently being used in Yoshii, Utashinai, and Mihama-Mikata, Japan, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, Farringdon, Oxfordshire, England, St. Lucie County and Tallahassee FL., and Hirwaun, South Wales.

If we can't stop the continuous stream of garbage trucks coming over the bridge from Canada, or from the south from Ohio and Illinois, perhaps it's time to start looking at ways Michigan can literally turn one man's trash into this state's treasure.  

Tags: , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
What an informative diary. (4.00 / 9)
I wonder if eartha or one of the other environmentally inclined posters would be willing to weigh-in on plasma conversion?

What are the downsides?

Maybe Dan or Jamie Scripps could jump in and give us their opinions? (I know they're lurkers and both environmental lawyers.)

It sounds very exciting... As long as there isn't some hidden evil that we aren't aware of, of course.  


good question (4.00 / 9)
I didn't mean this to sound all rosy and wonderful, but honestly I had a hard time finding negative effects that had scientific data to back it up. There was a town I read about that was claiming all sorts of things, but they thought they were being taken advantage of, and this was a few years back before there were any plants in the US. I did find that most of the companies developed their technology with grants from the gov't, one company in conjunction with the US Navy which later installed the converters on Carnival cruise ships. It will be interesting to see where this technology goes.  

Thank you for supportingDan Scripps!

[ Parent ]
It does sound promising but I did find these concerns (4.00 / 8)
in the Wikopedia link in the diary:

Concerns

Dioxin emissions are possible from plasma arcs when chlorine is present although the extremely high temperatures at which plasma gasification operates reduce this possibility. Process gas cleanup can be necessary when gasifying waste streams such as municipal waste streams known to contain heavy metals, chlorine/fluorine, sulfur, etc.

In 2004, the city of Honolulu considered a plasma arc/torch proposal for processing municipal solid waste. The city's Department of Environmental Services evaluated the plasma process and found that using plasma arc/torch technology would significantly boost waste disposal costs without offering worthwhile environmental advantages.[6] City of Honolulu press release, March 30, 2004: City to Brief Council on Plasma Arc Recommendations for Landfill. While some believe Federal funding is required to make better progress on this means of waste disposal (which is scientifically not the same principle as waste incineration), others note that basic thermodynamics show electricity costs to be unavoidably high when processing wet wastes such as municipal wastes, using plasma power alone. The technology of using plasma arc to treat waste has not changed significantly in principle from initial concept inception. Practical (limited use of land space for land-fills), technological (large-scale use of technology versus small-scale, e.g. plasma arc is currently favored as a means to destroy medical and hazardous waste), logistical (transportation infrastructure requirements) and budgetary considerations all affect the viability of individual projects. It is important to note, that at this stage, no municipal-waste disposal sized plasma arc facilities have as yet been constructed, and therefore they pose a considerable technological and budgetary challenge to even the largest municipalities.

An issue regarding plasma systems that rely on high temperatures for processing is in the life of their liners. The liner is an important aspect of separating the high interior temperatures of the plasma system from the [metal] shell of the plasma container. Liners are highly susceptible to both chlorine attack and to local variabilities in [high] temperatures, both of which would be found with typical municipal waste systems, and are not likely to last more than a year in service.

So like just about everything it might have it's downside but is definetly worth keeping an eye on.

The direct use of force is such a poor solution to any problem, it is generally employed only by small children and large nations.

 - David Friedman


[ Parent ]
saw that as well (4.00 / 7)
from what I can tell this technology is fairly in it's formative years, probably around 8-9yrs in actual production, not research. But as with everything does the good outweigh the bad? In this case it might. I would have to list a ton of data about the ecological impact of landfills and I just don't have the time....at least tonight I don't!  

Thank you for supportingDan Scripps!

[ Parent ]
All this intellectualism! (4.00 / 10)
I just can't handle it! Where's the diary about beer and cars? Sheesh!

heh (4.00 / 5)
ummmm I don't drink and you're the nascar fanboy. :O)

Thank you for supportingDan Scripps!

[ Parent ]
Actually (4.00 / 5)
saw a show called ecotech on discovery science. It had a segment on a plant in a town I can't remember the name of. So yeah, I came up with this post by staring at teevee.  

Thank you for supportingDan Scripps!

[ Parent ]
Better than landfilling by far (4.00 / 7)
Burying garbage in the ground is pretty primitive technology, because no matter how miraculous the liner material in today's modern landfills, they all eventually leak.

I hadn't heard of plasma arc gasification until I saw this post, so cheers for Adam and his TV habits (I might have to take up boob toob watching again myself).  A couple of minor corrections:  there are currently no large-scale PAG plants processing municipal waste in the U.S.--the ones in Tallahassee and St. Lucie County, FL, are the closest to coming online and according to this article they're still in the permitting phase.  I believe there are some very small U.S. operations being used to process medical waste, which the process is ideal for, as it obliterates every possible contaminent.

This Slate article does a nice job of summing up the pros and cons of the process:

So, why doesn't every hamlet in America do away with its landfills and build one of these wondrous plants? The plasma gasification industry claims it's mostly a matter of economics: Burying garbage has long been a lot cheaper than zapping it, even if you factor in the money to be made selling electricity. Landfills charge municipalities an average of $35 per ton of trash; according to a recent study in Hamilton, Ont., dropping off a ton of garbage at a plasma gasification plant would run $172 per ton.

Plasma gasification companies dispute this figure, contending that their method has become more affordable because of increasing efficiency in electricity generation: Canada's Plasco Energy Group, for example, says that 46 percent of zapped waste now becomes energy, compared with 18 percent with earlier plant designs.


This is the cost/benefit issue that led Honolulu to reject its plant initially as mentioned in the Wikipedia piece. I'm not impressed with even the most optimistic figure of 46 percent efficiency--this technology needs to be improved more, and it probably will be.  I do think the cost/benefit numbers would improve greatly if the demand for electricity went up because of the switch from gasoline to electric transportation.

This USA Today article lists some of the environmental questions surrounding PAG.  It says that the facilities already processing garbage in Japan are doing so on a much smaller scale than the Florida plants would.  However, the article doesn't mention that Japan's air quality standards are much stricter than ours.  If the plants are passing inspection over there, then critics can't very well say the process is unavoidably dirty.  The Slate article has some limited material on cleaning up the gas and slag byproduct.

The only legitimate criticism of PAG in my opoinion is that it provides an excuse for people to keep pumping out trash.  The biggest opponent is the Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives, (GAIA) a very vocal and well organized nonprofit with an international presence.  They're quoted in the USA Today article:

We've found projects similar to this being misrepresented all over the country," said Monica Wilson of the Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives.

Wilson said there aren't enough studies yet to prove the company's claims that emissions will likely be less than from a standard natural-gas power plant.

She also said other companies have tried to produce such results and failed. She cited two similar facilities run by different companies in Australia and Germany that closed after failing to meet emissions standards.


GAIA was formed to fight traditional trash-burning incinerators being dumped into third-world countries, which is a legitimate form of NIMBYism.  It raised red flags with me that a plant is being proposed for New Orleans (which has become a third world country of its own)--but then there has to be tons and tons of flood trash to get rid of down there, some of it hazardous waste.  Why not process it with PAG and get some use out of it, as long as the people of New Orleans benefit from the money saved?

And that's my quarrel with "GAIA": holding up a basically sound technology that needs tweaking here and there because you want to modify the public's behavior is immoral.  Humans will always produce trash.  Sure, we need to produce less of it, but this is one area where the marketplace will modify our behavior effectively, because the oil crisis is about to make wastefulness very expensive.

I tried to source GAIA's claims about the plants in Australia and Germany and came up with nada.  Does anyone have time to make a second pass at it?  It's probably the most important question surrounding this technology.  Thanks.

Earthanet.com - blogging for the environment


I just knew you'd have some good answers for us eartha! (3.83 / 6)
Thanks for weighing in!

[ Parent ]
Thanks for weighing in (4.00 / 6)
I had a very hard time finding data to back up negative effects. Alot of small towns that turned down offers made the companies seem like snakeoil salesmen. In regards to GAIA, they are comparing PAG to incinerating when they are two different concepts in regards to the system in which they run and the byproducts of the conversion. Incineration is inherently not ecologically sound because of the oxygen atmosphere that is involved. I do agree that PAG has a way to go, but it could be a very exciting technology.  

Thank you for supportingDan Scripps!

[ Parent ]
PAG (4.00 / 2)
  when you say solid waste do you mean all solid landfill waste or just solid sewerage?  Solid human waste can be turned into methanol.  Superheating plastic is probably not a good idea. Recycling it is.  We should be addressibng all plastics consumed in MI for recycling- not just Rs 1 and 2. All paper should be recycled.  All wood and metal and rock(concrete, asphalt).  There should be nothing in landfills exept human and food waste.  Both can be converted to methanol.
 We can't be cutting down Michigan trees much longer.  and plastic comes from guess where?- oil.  
 Recycling  will eventually be a staple industy.  Let's not wait until there is a lalndfill in every towm.



Grassroute Guide
Organizational Development, Team Building and Effective Leadership Training for Non-Profit Community Service and Advocacy Groups.



Get the essential tools and insights to develop and maintain a positive, "high-energy" in your grassroots community group.

Click here for ebook and video

BFM Welcome Center
Your BFM Menu:

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?

- About/Contact BFM
- BFM Privacy Policy
- Contribute To BFM

BFM To Go:
 - RSS Diaries and Blasts
 - RSS Recent Comments
 - BFM Newsletter
 - BFM on Twitter
 - BFM on Facebook







BFM Clicklist
· A2Politico
· Absolute Michigan
· ACLU of Michigan
· A Jared Manifesto
· Arbor Update
· Christine Barry
· Blue November
· Center For Michigan
· Conservative Media
· DailyKos Michigan
· The Deaf Edge
· Democracy for Metro Detroit
· East Michigan Blue
· Eclectablog
· Far Left Field
· Great Lakes, Great Times, Great Scott
· Ironicus Maximus
· Liberal, Loud and Proud
· Liberal Values
· Mark Maynard
· MI Blog
· Michigan Auto Insurance
· Michigan in Pictures
· Michigan Liberal
· Michigan Positive
· Motor City Liberal
· My Michigan Connection
· Opinion Artillery
· Our Michigan
· PhiKapBlog
· Positive Detroit
· Powers Court
· Reading For Leading
· Stone Soup Musings
· West Michigan Politics
· West Michigan Rising
· Wizardkitten
· Working in Bare Feet
· YAF Watch

Blogging in Color
· African American Political Pundit
· AfroSpear
· Angry Black B-
· Blabbeando
· Blac (K) Ademic
· Black Commentator
· Culture Kitchen
· Debra Dickerson
· Electronic Village
· Francis L Holland
· Jack and Jill Politics
· Jasmyne Cannick
· Keith Boykin
· La Shawn Barber
· Latino Politico
· Miss Wild Thing
· Oliver Willis
· Prometheus 6
· The Field Negro
· The Republic of T
· Rod 2.0 Beta
· The SuperSpade
· The Whichota NAACP Blog
· TransGriot

This list shamelessly jacked from PHB

Environment & Energy
· Black Bear Speaks
· [con]serving Michigan - MI League of Conservation Voters
· Dave Dempsey - Great Lakes Blogger
· Earthanet
· Ecology Center
· Greenflight EV
· Green Machines Tour
· Healthy Car
· Lead Free Wheels
· MI Network for Children's Environmental Health
· Network Green
· Save The Wild UP

The Establishment
· Call of the Senate Democrats
· US Congressman John Conyers
· Governor Jennifer Granholm
· Michigan House Democrats
· Michigan Senate Democrats





All content copyright Blogging For Michigan, 2010 All rights reserved unless otherwise specified.

Powered by: SoapBlox