B l o g g i n g   F o r   M i c h i g a n
Mobile Edition



Subscribe to our newsletter

Preview




S O L I D A R I T Y




BFM Video


President Obama Weekly Address: 1/30/2010


Gov. Granholm on CNN's "State of the Union"


Rep. Schauer Talks About High Speed Rail Jobs in Battle Creek


Pure Michigan- "Snow Day"


C3 - "Spirit in Action: You Cant Cross the Sea by Staring at the Water"

BFM YouTube Channel






BFM Hits   Granholm    Schauer    Bishop    Dillon    Economy    Senate Dems    Search BFM


More SCHIP lies, more flawed logic

by: Cordelia Lear

Sun Oct 14, 2007 at 19:35:59 PM EDT


From the Observer & Eccentric:

McCotter said a better way to improve health care benefits for children was to increase "the supply of health care."

Sorry Congressman. You're wrong. If a child doesn't have access because their parents don't have money or insurance, all the supply in the world isn't going to help.

His flawed logic continues


He said the problem isn't with SCHIP but that Democrats were trying to "plug holes in Medicaid."

"Poor people have to have more control over access to health care, more focus on preventative care, extend tax credits and help them to set up their own medical accounts," he said.


That's right. Never fix a problem with the current system. Heaven forbid we should try and improve it. And where pray tell do you think they're going to get the money to put in medical savings accounts? If you don't have a job, or are otherwise having difficulty making ends meet, a tax credit doesn't do you a bit of good.

But, you haven't heard the best yet. It's from Knollenberg.

Rep. Joe Knollenberg, R-Birmingham, in a letter to the Observer & Eccentric, argues that increasing the tobacco tax encourages people to take up smoking to support the bill.

That is one of the worst arguments I've ever heard  in my life.

Do you seriously believe that Joe? If you do, you ought to be ineligible for re-election by virute of insanity.

Cordelia Lear :: More SCHIP lies, more flawed logic
Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
You have got to be kidding me (4.00 / 1)
Wow.

Joe is a loon.


Makes you wonder (4.00 / 3)
what old Joe is smoking himself, doesn't it?

Disobedience, in the eyes of anyone who has read history, is man's original virtue. It is through disobedience and rebellion that progress has been made. --- Oscar Wilde, The Soul of Man Under Socialism

[ Parent ]
By Knollenberg's logic, we should reduce tobacco and liquor taxes to zero... (4.00 / 2)
Which would, of course, encourage people to stop smoking and drinking. The mind boggles.

"When you smoke and drink, that tobacco doesn't mix with alcohol and you feel lousy the next morning, so I gave up cigarettes."--former Tiger manager Mayo Smith.

Walberg too (4.00 / 2)
Must be in the "Desperation Dispatch" talking points because Walberg has been spreading that same crazy smoking argument. Unfortunately, the CitPat buys into the lies today:
President did right to veto SCHIP bill
http://blog.mlive.co...

I smoke. (4.00 / 2)
And I take a little pride in knowing that buying the same things that will eventually kill me from cancer will help kids who don't smoke, and yet, have cancer.

It's kind of ironic when you think about it:).

A voice in my head tells me not to be so mean to the conservatives.  I work very hard to ignore that voice.




BFM Welcome Center
Your BFM Menu:

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?

- About/Contact BFM
- BFM Privacy Policy
- Contribute To BFM

BFM To Go:
 - RSS Diaries and Blasts
 - RSS Recent Comments
 - BFM Newsletter
 - BFM on Twitter
 - BFM on Facebook
 - BFM on iTunes




BFM was Censored by Mike Bishop Aug 2-7, 2007

Twitter Michigan
- Governor Granholm
- Lt Gov Cherry
- Michigan Dems
- Progress Michigan
- Blogging For Michigan

For a more complete list, see our Twitter Michigan directory

BFM Clicklist
· A2Politico
· Absolute Michigan
· ACLU of Michigan
· A Jared Manifesto
· Arbor Update
· Christine Barry
· Blue November
· Center For Michigan
· Conservative Media
· DailyKos Michigan
· The Deaf Edge
· Democracy for Metro Detroit
· East Michigan Blue
· Eclectablog
· Far Left Field
· Great Lakes, Great Times, Great Scott
· Ironicus Maximus
· Liberal, Loud and Proud
· Mark Maynard
· MI Blog
· Michigan in Pictures
· Michigan Liberal
· Michigan Positive
· Motor City Liberal
· My Michigan Connection
· Opinion Artillery
· Our Michigan
· PhiKapBlog
· Positive Detroit
· Powers Court
· Reading For Leading
· Stone Soup Musings
· West Michigan Politics
· West Michigan Rising
· Wizardkitten
· Working in Bare Feet
· YAF Watch

Blogging in Color
· African American Political Pundit
· AfroSpear
· Angry Black B-
· Blabbeando
· Blac (K) Ademic
· Black Commentator
· Culture Kitchen
· Debra Dickerson
· Electronic Village
· Francis L Holland
· Jack and Jill Politics
· Jasmyne Cannick
· Keith Boykin
· La Shawn Barber
· Latino Politico
· Miss Wild Thing
· Oliver Willis
· Prometheus 6
· The Field Negro
· The Republic of T
· Rod 2.0 Beta
· The SuperSpade
· The Whichota NAACP Blog
· TransGriot

This list shamelessly jacked from PHB

Congressional Watchblogs
· The Audacity of Hoek
· Eye On Ehlers
· The Real Dave Camp
· Walberg Watch
· Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood
· Vote No on Joe
· Mad at Thad
· The McCotter Monitor

The Establishment
· Call of the Senate Democrats
· US Congressman John Conyers
· Governor Jennifer Granholm
· Michigan House Democrats
· Michigan Senate Democrats

Environment & Energy
· Black Bear Speaks
· [con]serving Michigan - MI League of Conservation Voters
· Dave Dempsey - Great Lakes Blogger
· Earthanet
· Ecology Center
· Greenflight EV
· Green Machines Tour
· Healthy Car
· Lead Free Wheels
· MI Network for Children's Environmental Health
· Network Green
· Save The Wild UP

Faith and Spirituality
· Pastor John
· St. John's United Church of Christ
· Pastor John's Sermons on Streaming Video
· Christ Community Church
· Aussie Heretic
· iAllison
· Cross Left
· Street Prophets
· United Church of Christ
· Sojourners - Christians for Justice and Peace

Financial and Economic Policy
· Lois Gibbons
· Harmony Financial Network
· Michigan Jump Start Coalition
· Michigan Jump Start Blog
· National Jump Start Coalition
· Michigan Credit Union League
· Michigan NSO

LGBT Community
Blogs

· Bloggin.Out
· Mostly Sunny with a Chance of Gay
· Rainbow Mittens
· The Political Spectrum
Organizations

· Lansing Association for Human Rights
· Michigan Equality
· Michigan Equality MI Idea Blog
· Michigan Pride
· PFLAG - Lansing
· Pride Source
· TransGender Michigan
· Triangle Foundation

Michigan Political Parties
The Democratic Party

· Michigan Democratic Party
· MI Blue Tiger Democrats
· County Parties
· Caucuses
· Congressional District Committees
· Benzie Dems
· Blue Chips (CMU Dems)
· Clare County Democratic Party
· Genessee County Young Dems
· Grosse Pointe Dems
· Isabella County Dems
· Kicking Ass (UM Dems)
· Living Blue (Liv Co Dems)
· Saginaw County Dems
· WMU College Dems

The Green Party

· Michigan Green Party
· Detroit Green Party
· Flint Greens
· Huron Valley Greens
· Ypsilanti Greens
· All MI Green Party Organizations

Other Minor Parties

· Libertarian Party of MI
· Socialist Party of MI
· Independence Party of MI

All content copyright Blogging For Michigan, 2007
All rights reserved unless otherwise specified.

Powered by: SoapBlox